Please use as a guide only
Conrad B. Teeter 1770-1840 son of Henry & Elizabeth
(Beidelman) Teeter of Springfield Township, Bucks Co., PA. Henry
Teeter 1743-1804 father to Conrad was a Revolutionary War Soldier,
Henry and his wife Elizabeth 1749-1804 are buried in Asbury Cemetery,
Lansing, NY. Conrad Teeter
married 1791 to Christina
Keller, daughter of Christopher & Christina (Bossert)
Keller, she died April 17, 1852 age 80 yrs old. Conrad
Teeter died July 18, 1840 age 71 yrs. They are both buried in the
Teeter Cemetery, Ithaca, NY. This cemetery was on the Isaac
Teeter Farm property.
Children found for Conrad
& Christina (Keller) Teeter are:
1. Susanna Teeter
2. Andrew Teeter born
Nov. 13, 1795 in Pa., died Jan. 18, 1887
3. Jacob Teeter born
July 31, 1800 married Elizabeth Unknown.
4. Rachel Teeter born
July 11, 1802 died Feb. 26, 1893 in Ithaca, NY. She married Reuben
Whitlock May 8, 1799 in NJ, died March 4, 1862, Reuben was the son
of John & Mary (Morse) Whitlock. 1850 Census has his birth
place as New Jersey, he is listed as a farmer in 1850, living in
Ithaca, NY. Reuben & Rachel are buried in Ithaca City
Cemetery, Ithaca, Tompkins Co., NY.
1. Mary Ann Whitlock
born Jan. 30, 1821 died July 2, 1900
5. Isaac Teeter, born Oct. 1,
1804 died Jan. 26th 1892, son of
Christina Keller. (In the will of Isaac Teeter it was stated for
the surrogate's court that Isaac Teeter died about the 21st day of
January 1892 at the age of about 87 yrs.
2. Katherine Ann Whitlock born
Oct. 20, 1822 died May 30, 1913 Married Edward Clinton b. May
12, 1822 d. Dec. 21, 1903 - both are buried in Ithaca City Cemetery.
3. Lucy Ann Whitlock born Oct.
9, 1826 died 1920 - married 1886 Miles McCutchen - Lucy is
buried in Ithaca City Cemetery, Ithaca, NY.
4. Julia Ann Whitlock born 1819
died 1896, married Alfred Dale born 1829 died July 18, 1910 -
buried in Ithaca City Cemetery
5. Conrad T. Whitlock born 1831
died Feb. 15, 1892 - married Elizabeth A. Baldwin who died
1928 aged 94 yrs. - buried Ithaca City cemetery. From
Landmarks of Tompkins Co., NY - MARSHALL, E. H., was born in November
14, 1859, in the town of Enfield, and was educated in the town of
Angelica in the district schools, finishing by a course under Professor
L. C. FOSTER at the Ithaca High School. March 18, 1886, he married
Rose, daughter of Conrad WHITLOCK, by whom he has two sons. In 1886 he
bought the WILLIS farm of sixty-three acres on which he raises grain
and hay, making a specialty of tobacco. He takes the Republican side in
politics and is actively interested in educational matters, being now
trustee of the school in district No. 3. Mr. MARSHALL is known in his
neighborhood as an active, energetic business man of ability.
6. Susan Ann Whitlock born July
15, 1835 died 1926 - buried in Ithaca City Cemetery, Ithaca, NY
7. Lorenzo R. Whitlock born
March 2, 1839 died March 15, 1917 married Susan (____). Lorenzo
Whitlock is buried in Ithaca City Cemetery, Ithaca, NY.
Married 1st 1829 to Phebe
children were all by his first wife Phebe Ann Carl, dau. of William & Elizabeth Carl, born
1810 died May 2, 1876. Isaac & Phebe Teeter lived in
Tompkins County, NY. It is said by Teeter family members that
Phebe went to California for some reason and she got scarlet fever and
she was buried in Calf., place unknown. Her children erected a
tombstone in her honor in Inlet Valley Cemetery, Ithaca, NY.
Phebe Teeter "Mother" of Martha, Henry and Eugene) d. May 2, 1876 age
66 years. Isaac Teeter married 2nd on Oct. 17, 1876 to Sarah
Theodore Nelson of Ludlowville, NY. Sarah was born March 12, 1830
died Dec. 1,
1903. See below for more on Sarah 2nd wife. It is unknown
were Isaac is buried, Teeter family members have been told he was
buried in one place (place unknown) then removed to another place that
his children felt was more appropriate (that location is also unknown)
Children of Isaac & Phebe were:
5. a. Andrew Jackson Teeter,
son of Isaac & Phebe (Carl) Teeter, born August 30, 1830 died 1908
age 78 yrs, married 1st March 28, 1850 to Sabrina C. Hamilton
b. May 29, 1829 d. January 30th 1852 aged 22 yrs., 8 mo's 3 dys.
Sabrina was the daughter of Andrew
& Elizabeth Cheesman Hamiliton, from the Town of Caroline, Tompkins
Co., NY, they had no children. Andrew married 2nd Phebe
who died 1853 age 30 yrs., no children by first two marriages, married
3rd 1857 to Mary Nixon who was born 1836, died 1917 age 81 yrs.
Mary was the dau. of George & Sarah Marie (Hamilton) Nixon.
Andrew, 1st wife Sabrina, 2nd wife Phebe and 3rd wife Mary are
all buried on the old Teeter Farm, Ithaca, NY (located near the Enfield
town line, on Gray Road).
In 1850 Andrew & Mary were living
in the Town of Caroline.
Children of Andrew and Mary are:
5. a. 1. George I. Teeter,
son of Andrew & Mary (Nixon) Teeter, born 1855/58, married Elnora
J. Sullivan, born abt. 1857 died 1940, dau. of William &
Susanna (Scott) Sullivan. Elnora was from the Town of Caroline,
NY. Her family lived on Brearley Hill.
Children: Zibbe, Andrew, George
5. a. 1a. Zibbe S. Teeter,
dau. of George & Elnora (Sullivan) Teeter, born 1882 died 1942
married Nelson F. Hopper born 1874 died 1939,
their children were: Elnora Hopper b.
1910 married Mr. Mead; Nelson Hopper born 1916
5. a. 1b. Andrew Teeter born
5. a. 1c. George Scott Teeter
born 1887 died 1962
5. a. 2. Charles A.Teeter,
5. a. 3. Arthur J. Teeter,
born 1878 died 1980 married Lena Susan Brown, born 1894 died
1965, she was from Candor, Tioga Co., NY, she
was the dau. of Frank James & Almina Cornelia (Burleigh)
Brown. Quote from the Ithaca High School 25 year reunion book -
Teeter, Arthur Jackson, entered from I. G. S., Sept. 1894; graduated
the Acad., 1899, Congress, Farming, 1899 to present , lives Ithaca,
NY. Children unknown - They had at least one dau. Catherine
Teeter born 1921 who married Robert M. Kellogg, son of Arthur M. &
Kellogg. Robert M. Kellogg was born Nov. 14, 1915 died Oct. 24,
2002. Arthur J. Teeter, Lena his wife, and Robert M. Kellogg are
all buried in Maple Grove Cemetery, Candor, NY.
5. a. 4. Lille M. , born 1877 (Foster child only)
married Walter Sheffield - She is only listed here because she has been
credited as being a daughter. She was not. This listing is
only to clear up that error. Her last name was not Teeter, it was
Lillian "Lillie" (surname may have been Watros) she came from PA.
5. b. Sabrina Teeter, born
5. c. Charlotte Teeter,
born about 1833 - Per Landmarks of Tompkins Co., NY - Charlotte
H. Teeter, dau. of Isaac Teeter married Elijah C. Hedges, born
Feb. 11, 1838 died Nov. 1883, their children were: Mrs. John Elyea of
Danby, Isaac Hedges of Kansas City, Lamont Hedges. Buried in South Hill Cemetery,
Coddington Road, Ithaca NY. Hedges, Elijah C. died Nov. 1883 age
54 yrs., 10 mo., 11 dys. His wife Charlotte H. Teeter 1833-1922.
Quote from Landmarks of Tompkins Co.,
NY - Hedges, Elijah C., deceased, was born in Caroline, February 11,
1838, and was educated in the district schools. At the age of
twenty-four he married Charlotte H. TEETER, daughter of Isaac TEETER,
who bore him three children: Mrs. John ELYEA, of Danby: Isaac, of
Kansas City; and Lamont, who lives at home. Mr. HEDGES was a Democrat
and took an active interest in educational and religious matters. He
had been in failing health for some years, so he left the farm and
bought a residence in the town of Ithaca, but failed to recover his
health, and passed away in November, 1883. After his death Mrs. HEDGES
took the management of the farm into her hands, and has achieved a
1880 was living in the Town of Ithaca
Near South Hill Cemetery location. 1880 census - Elijah Hedges
age 52 born NY, farmer; Charlotte his wife age 46; Ida, dau., age 24;
Isaac, son age 20, teacher; Lamont, son age 6.
5. d. Sarah Ann Teeter,
born July 2, 1836] (per the will of Isaac Teeter, she was Sarah
VanBuskirk, she was given the sum of seventy five dollars). I
believe her first husband was John VanBuskirk, born abt. 1832.
She married Jan. 23, 1907 John P. Taber, born Sept. 15, 1837.
Inlet Valley Cemetery, Ithaca, NY, has the following burials, believe
this is the correct family; John Van Buskirk, Father, born 1829 died
1908; ______? Mother born 1836 died 1914; Charles E., born 1865 died
1948; Rose Ann his wife born 1870 died 1954; Earl H., their son b. May
20, 1894 died May 20, 1901.
5. d. 1. Charles E. VanBuskirk born about
1865. Believe he is the one buried in Inlet Valley Cemetery,
Ithaca, NY. died 1948, married Rose Ann (______) born 1870 died
5. e. Susan
about 1838 (per the will of Isaac Teeter, she was Susan Cummings of
Willseyville, NY, the sum of one hundred dollars). Believe she is
Susan Cummings, wife of James. James died Nov. 17, 1870.
three children: William Henry; Hattie B.; Rosa Nell, all minors at the
time of his death. William Henry Cummings married Stella Mix,
at least at least two children, one name Pearl, and a son named Carlton
"Carl" Cummings. Rosa married Charles Edwards. [Rosa must
married twice, she is Rosa Maxwell b. 1870 in 1892 and 1900 with a son
Leo living with her mother.] (Thank you Nancy Cummings for helping
update this family). In 1910 Susan Cummings is living in Tioga
Co., NY with her cousin Orpha Carl Pierce, daughter of Peter Carl above.
Also buried with Charles and Rose Ann is Faustine Sarah Van Burskirk Schaafs, born 1907 died 1994
son Earl H. Van Burskirk born May 20, 1894 died May
5. f. Johanna Teeter,
born about 1843
5. g. Martha J. Teeter,
born about 1845 - Per Landmarks of Tompkins Co., NY - Martha J. Teeter,
dau. of Isaac Teeter married Mott J. Robertson, born Nov. 19,
1822, he was the son of George & Mary (Smith) Robertson and was age
46 when he married. Cemetery records for Willow Glen Cemetery,
Dryden, NY a Martha J. Robertson who died in Ithaca, is buried on lot
12-47 buried 1940 age 99 yrs. Mott Robertson is also buried
there, but no dates are listed for him. They are on the same lot
as George Robertson and Mary his wife. Quote from Landmarks of
Tompkins Co., NY. Robertson, J., was born in the town of Drained,
November 19, 1822. His father, George ROBERTSON, came to the
town in 1798, March 12, and was the first freeholder in the town of
Drained, and settled on lot No. 53, where his son now resides. He
received his education in the old eight square brick school house,
which was as quite a celebrated institution in its day. At the age of
forty-six he married Martha J. TEETER, daughter of Isaac TEETER,
of Ithaca. He takes the Republican side in politics and an intelligent
interest in educational and religious matters. Our subject has 175
acres of the original ROBERTSON homestead, and in 1891 bought
what was known as the James GILES farm of 220 acres, and has
nearly 400 acres of some of the best farm and wood land in his town,
where he is recognized as a practical and successful farmer. The family
originally came from Scotland; and has always been prominently
identified in the leading events of the day and in advancing the best
interests of the town. Captain George ROBERTSON has a family of
thirteen children, nine sons and four daughters.
1880 Dryden, NY near the Ellis Hollow
area. Census for 1880 - Mott J. Robertson age 57, farmer; Martha
J., wife age 35; Herbert VanDusen, listed as a son, age 18.
5. h. Jerome Teeter,
son of Isaac & Phebe Carl Teeter died 1846 age 26 days.
Buried on the old homestead family burial ground. Teeter
Cemetery, Town of Ithaca, NY
5. i. Mary Teeter,
born about 1847 (per the will of Isaac Teeter, she was Mary Masters of
Ithaca, NY, the sum of one hundred dollars) Believe she is the
Mary who married Lewis H. Masters Jr.
1900 Ithaca Census is L. H. Masters, born Dec. 1839 age 60 married 35
yrs., wife Mary born about Feb. 1845 age 55 mother of 2 children, 2
living., child E. D. son born May 1866 age 34 single; Anna B., daughter
born July 1873 age 26 single. Buried in Inlet Valley Cemetery,
Ithaca, NY is: Lewis H. Masters b. 1838 d. 1908; Mary A. his wife b. 1845
d. 1930. Also buried with Lewis H. and Mary A. Masters are
Margaret and Edgar; no last names or dates on headstone.
5. i. 1. Edgar D. Masters born abt. May 1866
single in 1900
5. i. 2. Anna B. Masters born abt. July 1873
single in 1900
5. j. William "Henry" Teeter,
(per the will of Isaac Teeter, he was William H. Teeter of Ithaca,
NY.) (LDS records - William Henry Teeter) born 1850 - Quote from
of Tompkins Co., NY - Teeter, William H., was born in the town of
Ithaca, December 18, 1852, on the old TEETER farm, owned by his
father, Isaac TEETER. He received a district school education
and has made farming his occupation. Mr. TEETER owns a farm of
ninety-five acres four miles south of Ithaca-a good grain farm-and
makes a specialty of tobacco. He has four children, Minnie and Ernest
by a former marriage. At the age of 35 years he married a daughter of
James OBORN, of Wisconsin, and they have two children, Willis
and Blanch. Unsure if this William above is the correct William
Henry Teeter. Date of birth is not correct. Inlet Valley
Cemetery, Ithaca NY has the following burial Teeter, W. H. b. 1850 d.
1902. (His first wife may have been Susan (____) born abt.
5. k. Eugene Teeter,
born about 1850/1853 (LDS records gives Eugene Teeter son of
Isaac & Phebe Ann Carl Teeter born about 1853 married about 1878 to
Catharine Paff born about 1857. 1880 census Enfield, Eugene
Teeter age 27, born NY, farmer, father born NY, mother born NY.
Wife Kate Teeter age 25, keeping house, born NY, father born NY, mother
born NY. Phebe Teeter, dau. age 4, Edith Teeter, dau. age 2.
Inlet Valley Cemetery, Ithaca, NY has
the following for Eugene Teeter: Teeter, Eugene F. b. 1852 d. 1936
Teeter, Catherine E. b. 1855 d. 1941
5. l. Frank Teeter, born about 1852
Isaac Teeter 2nd married Mrs. Sarah
Nelson (widow of Theodore Nelson) of Ludlowville, NY on Oct. 17, 1876 -
Sarah and her first husband are found living in Lansing, Tompkins Co.,
NY 1860 - Nelson, Theodore age 40, born PA; Sarah age 31; Sarah M. age
8; Lyle age 6; Jay age 4; with Dann, Martha age 23 living in same house
hold. Sarah also had at least two other children - Ida who died
Dec. 7, 1854 age 4 yrs. Elmer Nelson born about.1861 is living
with Isaac and Sarah in 1880. Elmer is listed as a step-son to
Isaac. Theodore Nelson first husband to Sarah (maiden name
unknown) Sarah's two daughters, Ida and Sarah M., plus Sarah her self
are all buried on the Isaac Teeter Family Cemetery. In 1868 Mrs.
Nelson (widow of Theodore is living in Ludlowville, and listed as a
dressmaker (1868-69 directory). One of the sons of Sarah
and Theodore Nelson is found buried in Inlet Valley Cemetery,
Ithaca. As follows: Lyle W. Nelson 1854-1924. Catherine
Lyle Nelson 1839-1928. For more information on Teeter
burials See Teeter Cemetery records.
6. Anna Eliza Teeter
born Nov. 5, 1807 died 1854 married Matthias Dill
7. George Keeler Teeter born
1809 died 1895 married Sally Ann Grover 1813-1895, 1872 they
were living in VanEtten, NY per the will of Sally's mother.
Quote: Sarah (Gray) Grover, wife of
Abel Grover, died Oct. 25, 1872 probate Jan. 14, 1873, Sons: David of
Enfield, Nelson of Ithaca, Samuel, Alpheus and Peter Grover all of
Ithaca; Daus: Sally Ann wf of George Keller Teeter of VanEtten, NY.,
Caroline wf. of George Teeter (son of Andrew Teeter) of Newfield, NY;
Emma J. Tompkins of Newfield, NY; Delia Marion of Ithaca.
Petitioner: Anson Grover of Newfield.
Believe this is the one found
in 1850 census, living in Ithaca, NY. Teeter, George K. age 40; Sarah
Henry D., age 12; George age 10; Emeline age 9; Ann Eliza age 7; Amanda
age 5; Helen age 4; Jerome age 1.
8. Catherine Teeter,
born abt. 1815 died April 9, 1853 age 38 yrs., 2 mo., 27 dys.
Married Charles Budd. Catherine is buried in Teeter
Cemetery next to her parents. Ithaca, NY, located on Gray Road.
1850 Ithaca census Charles Budd is found age 36; Catherine
his wife age 35; Christina Teeter living in same household age 78 born
Pa; Teeter, Jane age 35.
9. Christine Teeter, born 1817
died 1861 married Peter A. Deal
10. Jane Teeter, born
abt. 1815 - the only information on this dau. is 1850 she is living
with her sister and her mother age 35, unless she is a dau. in law to
Christine Teeter, wife of Conrad.
Also found is the record of: Ernest Teeter, son of A. J. Teeter died Feb. 17, 1911 age 30
It is unknown what family this Ernest should be listed with. This record was found in an old scrapbook from the Speedsville
area in the town of Caroline, Tompkins Co., NY.
Note: Buried in Ithaca City Cemetery are the parents of Mary Nixon: Nixon burials are:
Nixon, Abbie A., d. 1895 72y lot J 52
Nixon, William, d. 1868 49y lot J 52
Nixon, Emmett B., d. 8/15/1850 lot H/14/3
Nixon, George H., d. 6/17/1849 lot H/14/3
Nixon, Sarah M., d. 1/18/1872 w/o George H lot H/14/3
Nixon, Susan J., d. 12/21/1844 lot H/14/3
More on the Teeter family can be found at a second record of the Teeter Family History